I’ve made these two. I think I prefer the one on the right, but I’ll review which one I’m to use when I put them side by side with the rest of my set. I think both would look like they belong as I’ve used similar techniques to do them. However I’m not certain that the one on the right is completely planar geometry. Sometimes the planar geometry is a little tricky to review using the crease, and putting it on smooth shading doesn’t really help me much cuz it’s basically a giant ugly blob
I agree with the one on the right!